Whose decision is it?
Summary. Staying silent when a new task lands in a meeting is rarely about nerve. Robert Weller argues that whether a content decision is yours depends on two things: your job title and the number you’re measured on. A RACI matrix rarely settles it, because the metric quietly overrules the roles and the costliest decisions were never named. Drawing on his survey of people responsible for content and on cases from his own work, he offers a grid that sorts decisions into four moves, and a four-line record that turns a vague “we could” into a decision someone owns.
The editorial meeting is running over, and next week’s list is filling up. Someone more senior adds one more thing: a series, a new format, a quick piece “while we’re at it”. You can see what it will cost, the piece you meant to finish and the update that has been waiting since spring, and you don’t say it.
The meeting moves on. By the time you’re back at your desk, the item is on your plate, and you’ll deliver it whether you agree with it or not. Your objection hasn’t gone anywhere. It just never got said, so nobody could weigh it.
It’s tempting to call that a lack of nerve. I don’t think it is. Most of the practitioners I teach can tell me exactly what their team should stop doing. What holds them back in the room are two quieter questions: is this mine to object to? And if it is, what do I have to hold up besides my opinion?
Speaking up isn’t a matter of nerve. It’s a matter of knowing which decisions are yours, and those are written not only in your job description but in the number you’re measured on.
This article is about drawing that line before the meeting rather than after it. Which content decisions can you make? Which can you only put on the table? Which belong to the people next door? I learnt most of it the slow way, in hindsight, and I’ll show you where, so you don’t have to.
Why the RACI didn’t save that meeting
The standard answer to that meeting is a RACI matrix, and I teach it too. For each decision it settles who is Responsible for the work, who is Accountable for the call, who is Consulted before it and who is Informed after it. Its most common failure is that everyone is responsible, so nobody is. Its most overlooked line is the accountable one: that person decides, and for that they need influence or the authority to give direction.
In the textbook version, the extra item in that meeting meets a known owner, and the person whose decision it is makes it. If you’re consulted, naming the cost isn’t speaking out of turn; it’s what you were brought in for.
Here’s the trouble. Most teams have a RACI somewhere, in a project folder or on a slide from the last reorganisation, and the meeting still goes the same way. In my experience there are two reasons. The number you’re measured on quietly overrules the roles. And the decision that mattered most was never on the list to begin with.
The first reason took me years to see. Robert Simons, who studies accountability systems at Harvard Business School, defines what a person is accountable for by the range of trade-offs their measure lets them make. Hold someone to customer satisfaction or market position and almost everything is theirs to weigh. Hold them to an output count and there is almost nothing left. A narrow measure, in his words, is what you get when “key decisions are centralized, and few tradeoffs are allowed”.
Traffic is an output count. So are downloads, impressions and published pieces per month. If that’s what you’re held to, your measure has emptied the role. On paper you’re accountable. In practice there is almost nothing left for you to trade off, and an objection about trade-offs has nowhere to land.
I have also seen title and metric agree. For a while I led community and education, and that title gave me room to act on the education programme. So I treated one part of it as a sprint of two to four weeks.
I refreshed the newsletter courses my predecessor had built, put the sign-up front and centre on the website, and built a new course I knew would attract practitioners and bring more eyes to the others. Nothing was cancelled; a few things moved back a few weeks. The courses brought in a strong number of leads.
Nobody objected, and not because I argued well. Nobody had to: the decision sat in my job description, and the result showed up in the number leadership already wanted. That’s what it looks like when title and metric line up.
That’s rarer than it should be, and the survey I’ve kept open since 2022 suggests why.
What my survey says about room to move
Since October 2022 I have kept a form open called Content Marketing Responsibilities. It goes to people responsible for content, whether in-house, in agencies or working alone. It asks what they are responsible for, what they are measured on, whether they can reach their goals with the resources they have, and how freely they can move those resources around: choosing their tools, changing their team, bringing in outside help. My book uses the first 143 answers. What follows is a new look at those same answers, through two questions the book doesn’t print.
The first shows the gap between what people carry and what they decide. More than four in five of them produce content, and about four in five plan it. Only one in two set the goals the content is meant to reach. Just over one in three hold a budget. Of everyone accountable for a result, whether a strategic objective or an operational target, more than one in four hold neither budget nor the right to set goals.
Simons has a name for that distance between what you’re answerable for and what you command: the entrepreneurial gap. He argues there are often good reasons to open it on purpose, since a broad target with thin resources makes capable people work through others. Open it too far, though, and frustration and a fear of getting things wrong come back.
The second question is where it gets interesting. Among those who report little room to move their resources, nearly two in three say they can’t reach their goals with what they have. Among those with more room, it’s fewer than one in two.
And here’s what I didn’t expect: formal rights don’t change the picture. People with a budget or the right to set goals say “no” just as often as people without them, at just over one in two.
The title gives you a seat at the table. Your room to move decides what you can do from it.
So where do you sit? Could you change a tool, a member of your team or an outside partner this quarter without asking anyone first?
Hold all of this loosely. The sample isn’t representative: these are people within my reach, many of them my own students. They read my framing (goals too high, resources too few) before they answered. The link between room to move and reaching goals is weak, and it is a correlation, not a cause. The pattern is consistent enough to show you, and thin enough that you should test it against your own week.
Two decisions nobody made
The second reason is harder to see, because there’s nothing on the list to point at. A RACI can only assign decisions someone has named. The ones that cost the most are often the ones nobody named at all.
In one job, I heard three sentences again and again:
“Let’s just do it—here’s the first episode.”
“Once we’ve published two or three of these, we could …”
“What’s the MVP we can build to test it?”
The second one was mine. None of them is a bad sentence. Each sounds like progress, and none is a decision. Each moves a decision somewhere else: to later, to someone else, or to a test nobody told what to decide. Two of them cost me something I still think about.
The study is the one I still think about. We built it on qualitative insight and the customer and contact data we were able to collect, and from the start I saw it as more than a single asset. It had the potential to become the study people in that industry wait for every year. I said so often, in exactly that second sentence and its relatives: next time, we could …; after two or three of these, we could do X, Y and Z.
None of that went into the brief. Senior management treated the study as a short-term marketing and sales asset, something to show off, and measured it accordingly: downloads, leads, the number of completed self-assessments, and how often it came up in customer conversations.
Look at those measures again, though. Two of them, customers asking about the study and consultants using it to get a foot in the door for new projects, were early signs of a reference work, not a campaign. Nobody read them that way, because nobody had decided what kind of investment the study was.
That decision was never mine to make. Nor were the two things the annual version needed most. One was a decision to put the study at the centre, with the blog, webinars, podcast, newsletter and LinkedIn as its distribution rather than as channels running next to it. The other was direct access to customers, which sat with sales and consulting.
My mistake wasn’t that I lacked those rights. It was that I treated my assumption as if it had been agreed. I talked about the annual version as though it were the plan, and never once put it on the table as a decision that was still open.
Nobody decided against the annual study. Nobody decided it at all.
The podcast was the mirror image. Let’s just do it—here’s the first episode. The framing at the time was an MVP, a minimum viable test of the format. But one episode is not a minimum viable anything, and neither was the way it was made and handled once it existed. A test only decides something if someone has said beforehand what result would make you commit, and what would make you stop. The better question would have been the one A. G. Lafley and Roger Martin put at the heart of strategic choice: what would have to be true?
I didn’t ask it. I accepted that the first episode had simply been done, and used what I was given, because at that point it didn’t cost me my resources. I still think that was the right call on rights: it wasn’t my decision. What I skipped was the cheaper move, saying out loud that nobody had made it.
Map where your rights end
If the study taught me one thing, it’s that missing rights don’t end your strategic work. They change it. Strategic work on a decision has three parts: you surface it, you make it, and you hold it. Only the middle part needs the right to decide.
Surfacing means noticing a decision that was never made, one that was inherited, implied or settled by whoever asked last, and saying plainly that it’s still open. Holding means defending a decision once it’s made, in a room where someone outranks you. You can do both without a mandate. In the study’s case I could have done the first, and I didn’t.
Two questions decide which part is yours: is the decision mine on paper, and does my metric let me trade it off? Put them on two axes and you get four fields, each with its own move.
The Decision Rights Grid
Deciding which calls are yours, and what to do with the rest.
Mine on paper; metric doesn’t allow it
Rights on paper only
Fix the metric before arguing the call.
Example The extra item in the editorial meeting: yours on paper, held to an output count.
Mine on paper; metric allows it
Decide
Make the call, and own it.
Example Newsletter courses: my title gave me room, and leads were what leadership wanted.
Not mine on paper; metric doesn’t allow it
Next door
Ask to be consulted, or be informed.
Example The study’s annual version: not my call, and I never put it on the table as open.
Not mine on paper; metric needs it
Surface and hold
Raise it openly; ask for the mandate.
Example Customer access for the study: my metric needed it; sales and consulting held it.
Only the top-right field is fully yours. In the others, the work changes: fix the metric, raise the decision and ask for the mandate, or ask to be consulted. Read the axes as a lens, not a law. In practice, title and metric are often negotiated together, and moving a decision from one field to another is part of the job.
The other half of knowing your limits is knowing your neighbours. Every field next to content strategy owns a different question. Here is how I currently draw the lines:
| Field | The question it owns | Your part as a content strategist |
|---|---|---|
| Content strategy | What we make, what we refuse, and why | Decide, if your title and your metric let you |
| Governance | Who decides, and what protects a decision | Own the No-list; be consulted on the rest |
| Project and programme management | Are we building it right, on time, with the people we have? | Be consulted; stay informed on delivery |
| Content design and UX writing | Does this content work for the user at the moment they need it? | Set the brief, not the solution |
| Search, CMS and distribution | How content is found, stored and delivered | Be consulted, and listen: they often spot an undecided decision first |
| Sales and consulting | Who the customers are and what they ask | Ask for access; you can’t decide it |
| Leadership | Which goals, which budget and which measure | Offer a better metric rather than refusing theirs |
These aren’t borders to defend. They’re handovers. The point isn’t to keep anyone out of your territory. It’s to know, when a decision lands on your desk, whether you’re the one who should make it.
That also tells you when to get support. For every capability a decision depends on, ask three questions. Do we have it? Then use it. Can we build it? Then invest. Do we need to bring it in? Then that’s a decision too, and someone has to own it.
Where to keep a “we could”
When I went back over the study, one question kept coming up: where should a “we could” live, so it doesn’t quietly turn into a “nobody did”?
Not in next year’s calendar. A calendar schedules; it doesn’t decide. A slot in next year’s plan gets moved like any other slot, and nobody has to say no to it for it to disappear.
The initial hypothesis is the right place, but only if it’s written as a decision rather than a hope. That takes four lines:
- What kind of investment is this? A one-off asset, or the first edition of a series?
- Who decides whether it continues? One named person, not “we”.
- What would tell us it’s working, for this kind of investment? A series isn’t judged on first-month downloads. It’s judged on repeat use, on being cited, and on the conversations it opens.
- When is the decision due? A date, with the criteria from line 3 attached. That date is the only thing that belongs in the calendar.
For the study it could have read like this: first edition of a planned annual series; the marketing director decides on edition two by the end of Q3; criteria: how often customers raise it unprompted and how often consultants use it to open conversations, not downloads. Four lines, and the “we could” becomes something someone can say yes or no to.
It’s also the podcast’s missing question, written down before the first episode rather than after it: what would have to be true?
Draw your own map
You don’t need the right to make every decision. But you should know which ones you aren’t making right now, and who is making them instead. Most of the time, the answer is nobody.
So here’s the smaller exercise, and it takes less than an hour:
- List the five decisions that keep coming back in your content work. Can we also do X? Whether a channel stays. What gets retired. What’s good enough to publish.
- Before your next editorial meeting, mark each one: I decide, on paper only, I surface and hold, or it belongs next door. For on paper only, note the number that stops you. For next door, write down the neighbour’s name, and whether you’re consulted before their call or only informed after it.
- Read your metric as a job description. What does it let you trade off? If the honest answer is “almost nothing”, your first strategic decision isn’t about content at all. It’s about which number you offer to be measured on instead.
I don’t have a general answer for where content design starts or where project management stops in your organisation. It depends on who carries which number, and that varies more than any textbook admits. The map above is where I’d start. I haven’t tested it in a team yet, so read it as a first draft rather than a finished tool. I’d like to hear where your lines run, and where they keep moving.
The survey behind this article is still open, too. If you’re responsible for content, in-house, in an agency or on your own, you can add your answers. They feed my research and whatever I write next …
References
- Lafley, A. G. & Martin, R. L. (2013). Playing to Win: How Strategy Really Works. Harvard Business Review Press, ch. 8, section ‘Asking the Right Question’.
- Simons, R. (2005). Levers of Organization Design: How Managers Use Accountability Systems for Greater Performance and Commitment. Harvard Business School Press, ch. 4, pp. 88–95 (quotation: p. 93).
- Weller, R. (2027). Nobody Decided This. toushenne. Chapters 9 and 12.
Further reading (in German, on toushenne.de): Content-Strategie ist keine To-do-Liste, sondern eine Entscheidungsgrundlage, Strategisches Content-Alignment